StilaSmudge Stick Waterproof Eye Liner 0.28 g

I love these Stila sticks usually. They all have a really nice glimmer to them when you rub them in. However I've found with a few colours, this one included, that they have no staying power and come off within a couple of hours. The midnight blue is the best one as it is a harder pencil and so tends to stay on the longest. (I've started reviewing products I buy purely because it really annoys me, all those reviews with I got this for free for an honest review. I hope this helps!)

Purchased 2 of these sticks from amazon, after recieving one of these in an M&S promotional advent calender for Christmas 2018. They are fabulous beauty items and I chose amazon to purchase more from because of the range of colours. There didn't seem much difference in price wherever the purchase was made, so amazon was very convenient. But....On opening I returned one of the sticks (lionfish) immediately for a replacemnt because it was damaged/looked like it had been used. 6 weeks later the replacement item is no longer working. I have only used the item an absolute maximum of 20 times. I am now waiting to see how long the (stingray) lasts.Strangely, the item from M&S is still working after 10 months....I am giving one star, not because the product is bad, but because I spent £16 on something I cannot use and now cannot return. Just hoping the other stick doesnt turn out to be the same.

I love the eyeliner. It applies easily and stays on all day. My complaint is that there is hardly any of it! I wear makeup a couple times a week, and this eyeliner ran out in less than 2 months. I would say after 12 uses. Much much less than a traditional eyeliner pencil. I’m so disappointed because I like the product, but I feel ripped off with how short-lives my purchase was.

Smudges really quickly and dissolves after a couple of hours.No staying power

This is a great waterproof eyeliner that I keep returning to as it never lets me down! Marvellous colours to choose from and it stays the pace and I have tested them all through the years. I buy this one time and time again ! I do recommend it and like it so much I've given it five stars!

I brought this eye pencil and a L’Oréal one that was much cheaper. I won’t but this again as it is retractable and has already stopped working!!!!! Not what I would expect

This was no where near the quality I thought it would be seeing as it Stila, it’s not waterproof for a start. It does definitely smudge . I will not buy again. Not worth the money in my eyes

fake product.....just realised when reading oter feed back and then checking product pictures from Stila site and other trustworthy shops!!